Goodman vs American Standard

Are you a homeowner looking to invest in a new air conditioner or HVAC system? With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to make the right choice.

Known for their high-quality offerings, we’ll explore two popular brands, Goodman and American Standard.

By examining their features, benefits, and considerations, we aim to help you navigate the options and make an informed decision.

Let’s dive into the Goodman and American Standard world and discover which brand aligns best with your needs and preferences.

Table of Contents

1. Pricing & Energy Efficiency
2. Warranty Info & Reliability
3. Performance
4. Maintenance & Repair

Pricing & Energy Efficiency

Pricing is one of the most important factors when choosing an HVAC system for your home or business.

However, comparing the prices of central air conditioning systems can be tricky, as the HVAC industry typically does not publish them and prices may vary depending on the dealer, location, installation fees, and other factors.

To give you an idea, an American Standard air conditioner and furnace of 14 SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) may incur an average cost of $3,575 to $6,178, including installation fees.

For 2.5-ton models of the two popular brands, price estimates inclusive of installation costs are as follows:

Brand

Price

American Standard

$3,195

Goodman

$2,125

As you compare offerings from both brands, it’s important to recognize that home cooling can be costly.

Efficiency is an important point to consider when evaluating these two brands.

Energy Efficiency

SEER is the amount of energy required by air conditioners and heat pumps to provide cooling throughout a regular season. For the most part, the higher the SEER, the more energy-efficient the system is.

When it comes to energy efficiency, American Standard AC units takes the lead with a broader range of options compared to Goodman.

Let’s explore some of their standout units:

• American Platinum Z: With an impressive SEER of 20, this unit can reduce energy use by 60 percent compared to a central air conditioning unit with a SEER of 8. It’s an excellent choice for homeowners looking for top-notch efficiency.
• Silver SI: On the lower end range, American Standard also offers the Silver SI, which boasts a SEER of 13. While it may not reach higher SEER as the Platinum Z, it still offers significant energy savings and reliable cooling performance.

Goodman, on the other hand, provides a range of air conditioners with their efficiency ratings:

• High-End Goodman: Goodman air conditioning units can have a SEER of 18 on the high end of the spectrum, providing excellent energy efficiency and cost savings.
• Low-End Goodman: For those seeking a more budget-friendly option, Goodman also offers units with a SEER rating of 13 on the low end. While not as high as their top-tier models, they still provide reliable cooling at an affordable price.

Warranty Info & Reliability

Choosing between American Standard and Goodman systems involves considering coverage and reliability. Here’s what you need to know:

Warranty Coverage

• Goodman offers a standard 5-year parts warranty with product registration, extendable to 10 years. Some models even have a lifetime warranty on the compressor or heat exchanger, showcasing Goodman’s confidence in their products.
• American Standard offers a standard 10-year parts warranty, reducible to 5 years without registration. The longest warranty is 12 years on the compressor for select premium products.
• Both brands require authorized installation and have exclusions for normal wear and tear, improper maintenance, unauthorized repairs, and acts of nature.

Reputation & Reliability

• Both Goodman and the American Standard are two companies that have varying opinions on affordability, efficiency, and durability.
• Both brands receive good industry ratings from reputable sources such as Consumer Reports and Energy Star.
• Reliability data shows average performance for both brands, with variations depending on the specific product models.

Comparing warranty coverage and reliability, Goodman offers longer and more comprehensive warranties, including lifetime and unit replacement options.

However, American Standard excels in higher efficiency ratings.

Performance

Energy Efficiency: Both brands offer high-efficiency options, but American Standard stands out with its high-end AC units. These systems often come with variable speed compressors, providing precise and consistent temperature control while optimizing energy consumption.

Noise Levels: Goodman models are known for their quiet operation, providing a peaceful indoor environment. American Standard units also focuses on minimizing noise with features like insulated cabinets and advanced airflow design.

Cooling Capacity: Both brands provide a certain amount of cooling capacities suitable for different climates, homes and light commercial applications.

Maintenance & Repair

Regular maintenance and timely repairs are essential to keep your HVAC system running smoothly.

Here’s what you need to know about maintenance and repair services for these high-quality air conditioning brands:

Maintenance: Proper maintenance can prolong the lifespan of your cooling and heating systems and maximize its performance. Both brands recommend regular maintenance, including filter changes, coil cleaning, and system inspections. Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines and consider professional maintenance services to ensure optimal performance.

Repair Services: In terms of repair services, both HVAC brands have extensive networks of authorized HVAC technicians, like Emergency AC & Plumbing, trained to service their systems. This ensures that you can easily find qualified professionals to address any issues.

Lifespan: On average, HVAC units from both brands can last 10 to 15 years with proper maintenance. However, the lifespan may vary depending on usage, maintenance, and environmental conditions.

When comparing American Standard and Goodman, it becomes evident that both brands have unique strengths and caters to different air conditioning needs.

Goodman air conditioners balances affordability and performance, offering budget-friendly options without compromising reliability.

They provide a range of AC units suitable for families seeking to replace or upgrade their existing systems.

While they may not have the highest SEER ratings or cutting-edge features, Goodman AC units are made in America and deliver reliable cooling that can lead to significant cost savings for homeowners.

On the other hand, American Standard air conditioning is renowned for producing top-end air conditioners that prioritize quality and performance.

Their systems are ideal for homeowners in hotter or harsher climates, as they offer advanced technology and higher SEER ratings.

If you’re willing to invest in a trusted brand and prioritize top-tier cooling performance, American Standard is an excellent choice.

Ultimately, the decision between these two brands of air conditioning systems will depend on your specific requirements, budget, and preferences.

When choosing, it’s essential to consider factors such as whether or not the system is energy efficient, reliable, and any price variations.

Whether you are on the fence between Goodman or American Standard or another AC brand, you can always reach out to our local HVAC in Houston or AC specialists in Austin so we can help you choose the right system for you and your home.

We offer free estimates from a number of quality air conditioning companies and other types of home heating systems such as Goodman, Lennox, and Daikin so you can see which one fits your needs and budget.